operate

CHRISTIAN BREAKING NEWS: NY FORCED TO PAY $225K to Christian Photographer | Free Speech Victory for Emilee Carpenter [#EmileeCarpenter]

Christian photographer Emilee Carpenter just won $225,000 from New York State after refusing to photograph a same-sex wedding based on her religious beliefs. The case sparked nationwide debates on religious liberty, LGBTQ+ rights, and free speech.

Hi everyone,

New York State has agreed to pay Christian photographer Emilee Carpenter $225,000 to settle a major First Amendment lawsuit.

Carpenter, backed by Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF), challenged the state’s anti-discrimination laws that would have compelled her to photograph same-sex weddings against her religious beliefs.

QUICK REMINDER: Before we continue, please subscribe to receive more news stories like this on faith, law and freedom.

This decision comes after a four-year legal battle over her right to decline photographing same-sex weddings and it follows the landmark case Creative v. Elenis—in which courts have upheld that creative professionals cannot be forced to express messages contrary to their beliefs.

The state also will not stop her from:
Publishing a “Beliefs and Practices” policy.
Asking clients if their event involves a same-sex marriage ceremony.

Carpenter retains the right to operate her photography business in accordance with her religious beliefs. The state pays her legal fees and will not enforce the challenged laws against her. This strengthens protections for artists and creators nationwide who face similar service discrimination claims.

QUESTION: Should a photographer be forced to shoot a wedding that conflicts with their beliefs? Let us know your thoughts in the Comments section.

$225K Settlement Reached
According to ADF, New York State has agreed to a court-approved settlement in Emilee Carpenter’s lawsuit. The state will pay her $225,000 in legal fees, effectively concluding the four-year legal battle over her right to decline photographing same-sex weddings

Legal Protections Secured
As part of the consent decree:

New York will not enforce its public accommodations and publications laws to compel Carpenter to photograph or blog about same-sex weddings.

The state also won’t prohibit her from:
Publishing a “Beliefs and Practices” policy.
Asking clients whether their event involves a same-sex marriage ceremony.

Broader Implications
This outcome mirrors similar cases—such as 303 Creative v. Elenis—in which courts have upheld that creative professionals cannot be forced to express messages contrary to their beliefs. The settlement strengthens the legal boundary protecting expressive services from government-compelled speech.

Bottom Line
Carpenter wins: She retains the right to operate her photography business consistent with her religious convictions.

New York concedes: The state pays legal fees and will not enforce the challenged laws against her.

Expressive speech precedent solidified: This strengthens protections for artists and creators nationwide when facing similar service discrimination claims.

NY FORCED TO PAY $225K to Christian Photographer | Free Speech Victory for Emilee Carpenter | Desperate Search Ongoing | Christian Breaking News!

NY FORCED TO PAY $225K to Christian Photographer | Free Speech Victory for Emilee Carpenter | Desperate Search Ongoing | Christian Breaking News!